Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Colter's avatar

Really enjoyed this, I married a Mexican girl and we have a family and it’s really been interesting to see how they identify as they have grown. I would love to read more articles on this topic

Expand full comment
Philip's avatar

(1) Could you explain your definition of racism? The only notion of “biologically distinct groups” I can think of is groups that cannot interbreed, but obviously racists believe different races can interbreed: that seems to be one of the main things they’re worried about!

(2) You might consider how the racial identification of mixed-race people affects your analysis. This is salient to me: I’m mixed, but basically come off as White to people who see me, and more or less identify as such (of course I suddenly recall my non-White ancestry when applying to schools and jobs lol). Different mixes appear differently, and primary identification will affect the gene pool mixed kids enter, which will affect selection.

Also Whiteness itself is dynamic: the history of the Irish/Polish/Italians becoming White is well documented. Today, MENAs and Central Asians are often considered White. A lot of Hispanics identify as White, and I’ve heard terms like “White-adjacent” used to describe East Asians. I’m sure you’ve seen the memes about the surprising ethnic diversity of White Nationalist/Supremacist groups. All this to say, I wouldn’t be surprised if in the future, many more groups of people identify as “White”.

Expand full comment
34 more comments...

No posts